In any fermentation industry, if you are going to carry out a fermentation project it will have to be profitable or at least showing the potential of profitability. Fermentation industries are not charitable organizations that can carry out fermentation research for the purpose of esoteric activity. Money simply does not grow on trees and they have to account for their success or failures to the share holders. Esoteric research can only be carried out in public funded research institutes and universities where financial auditing is not strict and almost unaccountable (at least in this country)
Two of the weakest links in fermentation research here is that:
1 The scientists are very quick to extrapolate the profitability based on incomplete small scale research. This is risky since no scale up studies are properly carried out to test the technical viability of the process
2 They failed to audit the fermentation viability in terms of cost inputs but rather talk about potential market price. This is really a recipe for disaster! A lot of fermentations could be economically non viable if proper financial auditing is carried out
Do not talk about counting the chickens before they are hatched…it is just as good as a pipe dream!
If proper studies are carried out on the costings you might even see the project failure while still on paper
One of the most critical factors influencing the cost of fermentation is cost of energy. In the fermentation industries energy in the form of electrical power are required in so many steps of the fermentation flow
You need energy for heating, cooling, sterilizing, pumping, aerating, stirring and many more. So this must be considered as energy is a limited commodity and will increase in cost in future. Have these factors been thoroughly considered and taken into account before declaring to the world we have the technology to convert biomass to wealth by fermentation?
Type rest of the post here.
Read more!
Thursday, November 24, 2011
FERMENTATION ONLY MAKES SENSE WHEN IT’S BROKENDOWN TO DOLLARS AND CENTS
Thursday, June 4, 2009
THE ECONOMICS AND VIABILITY OF FERMENTATION WORKSHOPS
There are many fermentation technology workshops being carried out here and around the world. Since fermentation technology workshop is basically a academic business venture, profitability and viability of the fermentation technology workshops are important consideration to determine if the workshop is a success or failure as a business project. (Unless we consider the fermentation technology as a free public service, then it is a different story!)
Conducting of fermentation workshops could initially be seen as a business transaction between the “seller” and “buyer”. The seller is the party conducting the workshop and the buyer is the customer or client of the workshops
The seller will provide:
1 Laboratory facilities such:
Laboratories working space, laboratory facilities and equipments
inclusive of the various services
2 Laboratory consumables such as chemicals, media, laboratory
coats, protective mask, goggles and safety helmets
3 Array of fermentation equipments and ancillaries from upstream to
downstream depending on the type and specificity of costs
4 Arrangement for site visits inclusive of transportation if included
5 Teaching staff that include lecturers, consultants, facilitators and
support technical staff
6 Lecture halls and tutorial rooms plus all facilities for teaching such
as notes, stationeries
All these items must be itemized for costing. That includes:
1 Capital cost of equipments
2 Salaries and allowances
With regard to lodging and accommodation these are other factors which must be considered, usually the organizers will provide a list of hotels for the participants to choose and make their own arrangement
The critical points to be considered are:
1 Number of days of the course
2 Number of participants
3 Break point of profitability
It is not cheap to conduct such courses, unless you are willing to forgo profits or get the courses heavily subsidized or sponsored by the government or university for public relations exercise.
Fermentation technology workshops are not like the business, motivational, how to pass examination or even Feng Shui talks. These talks, workshops or seminars are conducted to large masses in hotels and are really pricey! Yet people are willing to come to these talks hoping for new ideas and they are willing to pay thousands of dollars for the privilege of attending such talks. Fermentation technology workshops are different. They are usually few registrants to the workshops. The investment in capital equipment for the fermentation technology workshop is high. So what is the right price to charge participants at fermentation technology workshops?
Even though there is a low number of participants for fermentation technology workshops, one should come up with a very reasonable charge or fees for the very expensive equipments used. Fermentors are very expensive equipments and are easily damaged by improper use or little care. The electrodes themselves are easily damaged by improper use or accidents. Some of the damages are cumulative and will not be detected immediately after the workshops. In the end the Department has to bear for the expensive repair and maintenance of the equipment. If you don’t take these factors into considerations the organizers themselves will end up paying more for the meager charges obtained in attending the workshops. In business this is called a losing venture. There must be business acumen in running these courses
It is simply ridiculous to rent or use the expensive fermentors at RM200 or RM300 daily. Car rentals are easily obtained at that price. Mind you the cars are cheaper!
I guess the clients of the workshops are happy and laughing their way to the bank! Its dirt cheap to pay at that price to attend the fermentation workshops!. (The organizers are happy too because they can proudly show their list of clients. He he he !!!)
Type rest of the post here.
Read more!
Friday, May 29, 2009
STREAMLINING FERMENTATION
The fermentation industry is not only labour but also energy intensive industries. Some of its products are facing intensive competition not only from the chemical industries producing the same products. In the case of certain fermentation products that could not be manufactured chemically this would not be a threat. The other threat is the competition from countries like China and India which could produce the same products but much cheaper
In order to survive any fermentation industries must be competitive enough to be able to produce fermentation products at a competitive price. One of the available methods to cut the cost of production thus lowering the final price of the products on the market is to be more efficient in its production. This would involve streamlining the fermentation industries in terms of improving efficiency of production, using less energy or using energy more efficiently
Streamlining could be referred as the improvement of an overall process, and the individual steps of the process, with a goal of meeting or exceeding client needs and expectations. The exercise of streamlining could itself be applied in many activities such as business, motorcar production, office management as well as fermentation industries
Stream lining is a rational exercise, whereby the whole fermentation process right from upstream to downstream is identified. The various steps involved are studied for room for improvement and whether they are run under optimal conditions. The success will be reflected in the end results that are expected. The company has shown much improvised financial performance in the last two years as a result of the financial as well as administrational restructuring that has been initiated during the period.
The fermentation industry is a dynamic entity that follows the sequence of events right up from upstream to downstream. It is often considered a one way flow. Any changes upstream in the streamlining process will affect the efficiency of the downstream unit processes. Care has to be taken to see that once streamlining process has been effectively carried out by not causing changes in operating regimes or even microbial contamination as the whole streamlining activity will be thrown out of gear. In the streamlining of the fermentation industries it is often a challenge to maintain this sensitive and optimal window of operations as the process is sensitive and fine tuned
IMPORTANT STEPS IN STREAM LINING
1 LOGISTICAL ARRANGEMENT OF UNIT OPERATIONS FOR SMOOTH TRANSFER SPATIALLY AND TEMPORALLY
The arrangement of the unit operations must be in logical sequence of the flow and must be within proximity of each other to allow smoother transfer between one process and another
2 SMOOTH VOLUMETRIC FLOWS FROM START TO END TO AVOID BOTTLENECKS
During the fermentation process there must smooth flow of materials being transformed right up from upstream, mid stream to downstream. The volumetric flows, materials and even man power must be considered
3 PROPER UNIT OPERATIONS ARE OPERATING EFFICIENTLY
The proper unit operations of the right capacity and specifications must be used. The equipments must be efficient and in good order and functioning properly. In certain situations there must be stand by units in case of emergency failures
4 FERMENTATION FLOW IS CLOSELY MONITORED BY SENSORS AND UNDER FULL CONTROL OF FEED BACK LOOPS
In this age of automation, sensors, computers and feedback loops will give us the immediate status of the process temporally as well spatially. This computer displays allow us to look graphically at the process and detect where likely trouble spots will occur or any build up of problems in the process
5 NEED OF SOPs
The use of SOPS will allow consistency of process, materials and products and avoid sudden problems occurring
6 NO ROOM FOR CHANGES
If in the application of streamlining is carried out, any sudden changes may affect the streamlining. Therefore it is important no sudden changes are carried out suddenly. In fermentation using non homogenous substrate composition this can be a challenge!
Type rest of the post here.
Read more!
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
IMPORTANCE OF FERMENTOR DESIGN IN MINIMIZING ENERGY CONSUMPTION AND INCREASING YIELD
The main function of the fermentor tank is to hold the volume fermentation broth. In fact any vessels or container can be used to carry out the fermentation process. Fermentors differed from any container by allowing optimal fermentation process to occur through design and control
It is almost unbelievable that the concept of CSTR still dominates the day, years after its inception during penicillin fermentation. Only lately have attempts been made to come up with fermentors with novel or new designs.
The change towards new design fermentors is more to:
1 New fermentation products
2 Shift from high volume low value products to low volume and high value products
Any changes in the fermentor design must be with the purpose of improving the efficiency of the fermentation process in terms of yield and productivity or increasing its mass transfers and lowering energy consumption
In the old days it seems that almost any product fermentation is just forced into the CSTR. This was the mental block that hover over most engineers and fermentation technologists that one fermentor can be used for all types of fermentation!. It just doesn’t make sense!
Nowadays the design of the fermentor is more to accommodate the demands of the type of fermentation process. It seems in the past the engineers building or designing the fermentors are not able to think outside the box. The rigidity of their thinking is as rigid as the fermentor design
The fermentation process is considered complex with physical chemical and microbiological continually changing. With this in mind the design of fermentors must always be responsive. The fermentor design must not only be looked upon as fixed unit processes undergo by the fermentor such as standard stirrer specifications, aeration and even the sterilizing specifications. It is doubtful one standard design fermentor can bring out the best for a variety of fermentation carried out in the lifetime of the fermentor.
So, it is back to the drawing board in the design of the fermentors and a compulsory re education in fermentation technology for those involved in the design of fermentors. Reengineering and novel engineering is a must for the future of fermentors and fermentation.
The trouble with the design of fermentors in the past is that there is too much emphasis on engineering and math with poor understanding of the fermentation process. Sheets and sheets of the blueprint is the testimony to this
It is recommended that:
1 Understand the fermentation process first
2 Determine the rate limiting steps of the fermentation process
3 Understand the characteristics of the fermentation broth
4 Carry out feasibility lab studies before the design is accepted
5 Determine the flow and mixing pattern of the fermentor before determining the final optimal geometry
6 And other relevant studies
The key performance index in all the designs of the fermentors is cost. One of the major liabilities is energy. A fermentor is not a dead or innate structure metaphorically speaking. It consumes and even generates energy depending on the situation. Energy costs may not be a problem if you are dealing with small fermentors or working in government fermentation laboratories. But in industries, the energy costs could be very prohibitive and will add cost to the final fermentation products
If we analyse the energy consumption in a typical fermentor, most of the energy requirements are for:
1 Aeration
2 Stirring
3 Heating and cooling activities
Aeration is necessary in any aerobic fermentation process. The amount of aeration should reflect the oxygen demand of the fermentation process at that temporal and spatial status. What is important is that the aeration process should always be able to provide enough oxygen in the narrow window during the fermentation process. Providing more not only add up to the energy costs but might even complicate the fermentation process. Insufficient aeration might result in certain zones of the fermentor being deprived of oxygen and affect the fermentation process
In deciding the aeration requirements we have to consider many factors such as:
1 Type of aerators or spargers used
2 Location of spargers within the fermentors
3 Demand of oxygen as function of time of fermentation progress
4 Presence of mixers or stirrers in fermentors
5 Feed back loops to stirrer and aerator volumetric rate
Easier said than done. There is really no such thing of using the optimal aeration conditions of one fermentation process to be used on another. No two fermentations are the same. The optimal aeration conditions for fermentation have to be individually determined. This itself is the problem of having customized designed fermentor as it might only be suitable for one type of fermentation and not another
It is a known fact that experience in fermentation beats all the formal knowledge or information from books.
The choice of aerator is important and will decide whether the aeration costs will be higher or lower. It has been shown that aeration by air compression is only about 40% efficient in terms of electrical energy while agitation by turbine is about 90% efficient. Surprisingly in my experience as consultant on a trouble shooting job I have seen many clients are convinced by very qualified engineers who proposed air compression. Poor clients!
Use of sensors n feed back lops important. We need a reactive fermentor to detect changes and operate within narrow window of process optimization
Whole objective of stirring to homogenize or keep broth in suspension. How powerful we stir are often determined by the nature of the rheology of the fermentation broth. Mixing and aeration should be interplayed where a compromise is made between keeping the components of the broth in suspension yet still keeping the minimal amount of dissolved oxygen concentration enough to support the needs of the microorganisms. Excessive stirring may not only be demanding on the energy but also damaging to the microorganisms
Type rest of the post here.
Read more!
Wednesday, May 21, 2008
INDUSTRIALIZATION OF TRADITIONAL FERMENTATION INDUSTRIES (2)
We will now discuss in detail on how to go about industrializing a hypothetical traditional fermentation industry. We will approach this by asking a few questions
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
1 What are the various types of fermented foods available in the region?
2 Which fermented food has the highest demand or consumption?
3 Is there a projected increase in the demand for the fermented food in the future?
4 Is the profit margin high enough to make the project viable?
5 Can the marketing be extended to larger areas?
FERMENTED FOOD
1 What are the raw materials needed for the fermented food?
2 Is the raw material easily available locally?
3 Is the cost economical and stable?
FERMENTATION PROCESS
1 Is the production a low level fermentation technology?
2 Outline the process flow in the production of the fermented food
3 What are the rate limiting steps or bottlenecks in the production process?
4 Can these rate limiting steps be improved through use of manpower or mechanization?
5 Will the increase in production costs justify increase in profit by increasing volume of production and lowering of cost per unit produced
6 Will scaling up or economy of scale work?
7 Can SOP be introduced to the production process for better consistency and quality control?
8 Can the production process be improved from batch to continuous production?
PRODUCT
1 What is the shelf life of the fermentation products?
2 Can the shelf life be improved by better packaging and refrigerating
Type rest of the post here.
Read more!
Thursday, January 31, 2008
STREAMLINING FERMENTATION- PROFIT OR EFFICIENCY?

(THE PICTURE TAKEN FROM WWW.SRC.SK.CA)
Economics is the single factor that dictate whether a particular industrial fermentation process is viable despite the fermentation process being technically viable. There is always the need to produce fermentation products at minimal costs so that the product will be cheaper on the market in the face of stiff competition from other producers
Various strategies are often taken to cut the production costs down such as:
1 Producing higher volume of the fermentation products using larger fermentors
2 Using cheaper source of fermentation raw materials
3 Cutting wastage of materials by using it efficiently
4 Making the fermentation process more efficient by using higher producing strains or better unit processes in the fermentation process
There are times however where the fermentation companies see a potential increase in demand for their fermentation products and decided that whether it is the best option to consider enlarging the capacity of their production by increasing the number and size of fermentors? This is a very risky decision to take as increasing the number and size of fermentors is a very huge investment in capital. Would it not be better if we can increase the efficiency of the existing fermentation process to its most achievable limit of optimization before deciding if an increase in production capacity is a viable option
While it is true that increasing the numbers and size of fermentors could increase the production capacity of the company, but if it is run at the same inefficiency as before there is going to be a high increase in the amount of potential wastes from operating costs to wasted fermentation media
The most important step therefore is to find ways of increasing the efficiency of the existing fermentation process and find at which step from the upstream activities to downstream activities where they are found to be rate limiting to the whole fermentation process. Proper analyses or studies must be carried out in terms time spent at each step.
TIME IS ESSENCE
---------------------
try shortening it at each unit until total efficiency objective is reached at each component step. This even include the CIP/COP times! Use a more efficient method of cleaning and more effective chemicals. This will allow a shorter turn around time for the fermentors to be reused again!
If every unit or steps in the fermentation process makes effort and improve their efficiency and time management then the overall fermentation process will be improved.
Meetings must be held regularly to see how the new fermentation run schedule could be further improved with the increase in efficiency and overall shortening of the time
Secondly, even the rate limiting steps are identified and adjusted, it might create different bottlenecks down stream to the rate limiting steps. Fermentation process is a dynamic process whereby any step changed upstream will affect the various downstream steps. There will also need to be changes to be carried out upstream to accommodate the different flow rate to the primary recovery step
ANALYSES OF THE RATE LIMITING STEP
------------------------------------------------
We can picture the industrial fermentation process involving the four main stages:
PRECULTURE --> FERMENTATION-->PRIMARY RECOVERY -->DOWNSTREAM PROCESSING
It is very obvious from the above flow chart that the most rate limiting step is the primary recovery step. Any change in the primary recovery step positively will also mean changes both upstream and down stream to the primary recovery step. Adjustments in both directions have to be made
FACILITATING THE FLOW
---------------------------
In any industrial fermentation process could be seen as a series of events occurring or passing through a series of unit processes which end up as the 'packaged product' at the end. A good fermentation production floor is no better than a kitchen at home. A well designed kitchen equipped with the proper equipments and tools at the right place properly positioned will help improve the fermentation cooking process
The flow of the fermentation process must be maintained efficiently with no hold up and proper equipments in placed
Side activities that enter into the flow such as media preparation, sampling and analysis must enter the flow at the right time and place
Read more!